---
title: The Netherlands Will Return a Göring-Looted Van Goyen From the Mauritshuis to the Goudstikker Heir
description: The Dutch state will return Jan van Goyen's Fishermen by the Lakeshore from the Mauritshuis to Marei von Saher, weeks after Argentina returned a lost Ceruti.
author: Dr Marina Nani (Editor-in-Chief)
date: 2026-10-03T09:00:00.000Z
updated: 2026-11-04T11:12:12.672Z
canonical: https://www.richmanmagazine.com/article/van-goyen-mauritshuis-goudstikker-restitution
image: https://cdn.nanimediahouse.com/van-goyen-fishermen-lakeshore-goudstikker-383843.webp
categories: Culture
content_type: News
region: Netherlands
publication: Rich Man Magazine
schema_type: Article
---

The Dutch state is giving back "Fishermen by the Lakeshore", a small 1651 landscape by Jan van Goyen that hangs in the Mauritshuis in The Hague, to Marei von Saher, the heir of the Jewish art dealer Jacques Goudstikker. The Netherlands' Restitutions Committee found that the painting went into Hermann Göring's collection in June 1940, weeks after Goudstikker died fleeing the German invasion, and advised the culture minister to return it. The minister adopted the advice, which was made public on 18 September 2026.

"After more than eighty years, this painting is finally being restored to my family," said Marei, the widow of Goudstikker's only son, Edo von Saher.

Van Goyen painted the scene only in shades of brown, on paper reinforced with canvas, and it measures 25 by 34 centimetres. He marked it with his monogram and the date, "vG 1651". The painting is part of the Dutch National Art Collection under inventory number 979 and is on display at the Mauritshuis. The Dutch government bought it for the museum in January 1967 from the dealer Saam Nijstad, paying 58,000 guilders.

The Mauritshuis says the painting's origins were hard to trace because van Goyen was extremely productive and painted many landscapes of this type and size. Its researchers worked with the Goudstikker heirs' research team to establish that the picture came from the dealer's trading stock.

The painting was not identified in the family's earlier restitution requests, The Art Newspaper reports. Judith Niessen, the Mauritshuis's head of collection and research, told the paper: "We bought the painting in the 1960s in good faith and of course we are sad that we're going to have to say goodbye." She added: "But it doesn't belong to us: it left the Goudstikker collection in an unjust way."

## Göring Had the Painting Before Any Sale Contract Was Signed

Goudstikker was one of the leading Dutch art dealers between the wars, specialising in [Dutch, Flemish and Italian old masters](https://www.richmanmagazine.com/article/rembrandt-etchings-old-drawer-zutphen). After Germany invaded in May 1940, he, his wife Dési and their infant son, Edo, got berths on the steamer SS Bodegraven at IJmuiden, bound for England. During the night of 15 to 16 May he fell into the ship's hold while walking on board and died. He had taken with him a black notebook listing the gallery's trading stock, 1,113 inventoried works by the Restitutions Committee's count. Nineteen of them are by van Goyen, and the committee found that one, number 2965, has similarities with the Mauritshuis landscape in its dimensions and description.

The Amsterdam gallery was left unsupervised, and documents in the German Federal Archives in Koblenz show that the van Goyen became part of Göring's collection in June 1940. The sale to Göring was signed only on 13 July 1940, by Arie ten Broek, a gallery employee whom an invalid shareholders' meeting had made managing director on 4 June. Under that agreement Göring paid two million guilders for the rights to every artwork the gallery owned in the Netherlands as of 26 June 1940. Dési Goudstikker, who held 334 of the firm's 600 shares, never agreed to the sale, and the committee found that alone was enough to treat the loss as involuntary. Shipping works to Germany before a contract existed, [the committee wrote](https://www.restitutiecommissie.nl/en/recommendation/goudstikker-iii/), "is consistent with the well-known image of the Nazi authorities as people who robbed or bought under duress and then gave such acts an appearance of legality."

## A Van Goyen Expert Bought the Landscape at a Berlin Sale in 1957

US records show that paintings were stolen from Göring's art train at Unterstein station in Bavaria in May 1945, and the committee thinks the van Goyen may have been one of them. That would explain why it was not sent back to the Netherlands through a Central Collecting Point like other works from Göring's collection. It appeared at a sale at the Leo Spik gallery in Berlin in November 1957, where the art historian and van Goyen expert Hans-Ulrich Beck bought it on 26 November for 5,000 deutschmarks. Beck sold it on to Nijstad, the dealer the Dutch government later bought it from.

## A 1999 Court Ruling Stood in the Way of the Claim

Marei asked the Dutch state for the painting in a letter of 17 November 2023, and the committee heard the case on 27 October 2025. The main obstacle was a judgment of the Court of Appeal in The Hague of 16 December 1999, which rejected an earlier claim brought by the gallery's successor company and found that the dealership had deliberately chosen not to seek restoration of its rights over the Göring sale. Under the committee's usual rules that judgment barred the claim, but the rules also let the committee depart from them when there is a compelling reason. It pointed to 2006, when the State Secretary for culture decided that the 1999 ruling put the Goudstikker case outside restitution policy and returned the works the family had claimed anyway, citing the facts of how the gallery lost them. The committee followed that reasoning in 2013 and has applied it again to the van Goyen.

## A Portrait Spotted in an Argentine House-Sale Photo Is Being Returned to Marei

Two weeks before the Dutch advice was made public, a federal judge in Mar del Plata, Argentina, approved the return of another Goudstikker painting to Marei: "Portrait of a Lady" by the Italian painter Giacomo Ceruti, who lived from 1698 to 1767.

The Dutch journalist Peter Schouten travelled to Mar del Plata in April 2025 to follow a lead. A house in the city's Parque Luro district was listed for sale on an estate agent's website, and one of the photos showed a painting in the living room that matched a work missing from the Goudstikker collection. The Dutch newspaper Algemeen Dagblad published the story on 25 August 2025, and Interpol Argentina reported the painting to federal prosecutors in Mar del Plata the same day.

When investigators searched the house on 26 August, another picture hung where the portrait had been, and a mark the size of the missing work was still visible on the wall. Prosecutors charged the couple who had kept the painting with aggravated concealment, saying they had held it since at least 1979, and their lawyer handed it over on 3 September 2025.

Argentine prosecutors say the painting belonged to Goudstikker until at least July 1940 and later passed to Friedrich Kadgien, a German official who held posts in the Third Reich's economic and finance administration. The account of the case attached to the court agreement says it reached the family of one of the accused through her father, Kadgien, who died in 1978.

The portrait had long been attributed to the Italian portraitist Giuseppe Ghislandi. Ángel Miguel Navarro and Alejo Gabriel Lo Russo, specialists from Argentina's National Academy of Fine Arts, attributed it to Ceruti, known as "Il Pitocchetto", and said it could be worth around €250,000.

On 4 September 2026 Santiago Inchausti, the federal guarantees judge in Mar del Plata, approved an agreement between federal prosecutor Carlos Martínez and the defence. The couple gave up any claim to the painting and agreed that it be returned to Marei. The criminal case against them is suspended for two years, during which each must donate 2.4 million pesos to the support association of the city's Hospital Materno Infantil and follow conduct rules set by the court. Martínez described the agreement as a historic reparation for the victims of the case.

The decision goes to Argentina's Supreme Court, which holds the portrait for safekeeping, to settle how it is handed over. Marei's lawyers told the court she would like it to stay in Argentina for a time and be shown to the public, to raise awareness of the Nazi plunder of art. Her Argentine lawyer, Juan Ignacio Pascual, told The Art Newspaper that "as far as we know" it is the first time Argentina's justice system has recovered and returned a painting looted by the Nazis.

## The Family Is Still Searching for Hundreds of Goudstikker Works

The Dutch state returned 202 Goudstikker works to Marei in 2006, out of 267 claimed for the family, and three more paintings in 2013. The van Goyen is the third Dutch restitution to the family.

Yaél M. Weitz of Freedman Normand Friedland, the family's lawyers, says the family is still searching for hundreds of works from the Goudstikker collection, and that she hopes the two returns "will [encourage others to act in a just and fair manner](https://www.richmanmagazine.com/article/italy-nazi-looted-art-restitution-panel)." In the Netherlands, the government is re-examining the provenance of the entire NK collection, the art returned to the Netherlands from Germany after the war, as part of a programme to step up its restitution policy.

## FAQ

**Q: Who was Jacques Goudstikker?**
Born in 1897, he joined his family's Amsterdam gallery in 1919; his grandfather and great-uncle had founded it in 1845, and from 1927 it stood at Herengracht 458 on the Golden Bend. After his death at sea in May 1940, his widow and son travelled on to Canada and later settled in New York.

**Q: Why are works from Göring's collection still being claimed?**
When Goudstikker's widow settled her claims over the gallery's wartime sales with the Dutch state on 1 August 1952, the works delivered to Göring were left outside the settlement. Claims to those works, such as the van Goyen, are still decided case by case.

**Q: What is the Dutch Restitutions Committee?**
It advises the Dutch Minister of Education, Culture and Science on claims for cultural property lost during the Nazi era, and Toon van Mierlo has chaired it since 2023. Under rules in force since 22 April 2021, when the state holds the work the committee only has to establish original ownership and involuntary loss, and it no longer weighs the museum's interest against the claimant's.

**Q: Who was Jan van Goyen?**
Jan van Goyen (1596 to 1656) was a Dutch landscape painter, born in Leiden and trained in Haarlem with Esaias van de Velde. He moved to The Hague in 1631 and worked there for most of the rest of his life.
